I like all tacky boxes. What sets them apart is the silicone back and its durability (great material and magnets). The only thing I don't like is that I have to open it up to look at the flies. This set up allows you to obviously double the flies that could be in the box. But I prefer to actually see them and decide which ones I want to grab before opening the box. So I personally prefer the one with the clear cover. But either way, you can't go wrong with these boxes

The quality of the rubbery material holds the flies amazingly well. It does not seem like it will age like the foam and the flies are very easy to remove.

Magnetic closure is easy and there is no doubt that my flies will stay in place during transport.